Frequently Asked Questions

Do you have a question?

Please read the objections page for our response to objections made to LVT.

Please contact us if your question is not answered here.

Before you do, please carefully read the definition of LVT:

LVT is an annual,
nationally determined,
nationally collected,
percentage tax,
paid by the freeholder,
on the open market value
of all land
with no exceptions.

The definition is broken down in the "What is LVT?" article.

NO EXCEPTIONS

What about stately homes and country houses?

"No exceptions.". Note: LVT is a tax on the value of land only.

We love Chatsworth. It's a beautiful house, lovely garden, idyllic setting and fantastic estate with miles of walks - and the farm shop in nearby Pilsley is pretty good too - if pricey - £3.95 for a bottle (500ml) of beer! The estate provides employment for over 1,000 people, it is very well run and, from the many conversations we have had, people love working there.

We are not philistines, we don't want places like Chatsworth to be pulled down in the same way so many country houses were pulled down in the 1950s.

We say this even though the Cavendish family (via Gernon de Montfichet and Robert de Gernon) received stolen land after The Great Theft of 1066 and John Cavendish assisted William Walworth in the murder of Wat Tyler, one of the leaders of The Great Rebellion of 1381. The Cavendishes went on to suppress other revolts against the landowning class and the money for Chatsworth came from the labour of those who spent their lives digging the coal found on the land the family received as stolen goods.

These places are not "national assets" or "public resources", they are private organisations run as businesses.

  • Chatsworth is in the hands of a trust - to avoid tax.

  • Chatsworth is a charity - to avoid tax and to benefit from other tax breaks granted to charities.

  • Chatsworth is a business and should be treated as a business.

  • Chatsworth house and gardens were created by the labour of stone masons, builders, architects, plumbers, electricians, joiners, plasterers, painters, gardeners, designers, foresters, labourers etc.

  • Chatsworth's interior contains objects created by the labour of sculptors, cabinet makers, jewellers, potters, painters, dress makers, milliners, weavers etc.

  • Chatsworth was paid for by the labour of peasants, farm tenants and coal miners.

  • The Cavendishes acquired it from ancestors willing to kill to steal it and keep it.

  • The Cavendishes have contributed nothing yet they own it all.

Stately homes frequently have large amounts of land associated with them and that land generates income from farming rents. Chatsworth has 35,000 acres and the Devonshires also own the Bolton Abbey Estate in Yorkshire, Lismore Castle in Co Waterford and Compton Place in Eastbourne. In 1907 the family owned 192,322 acres across the British Isles - this had been reduced to an estimated 73,000 acres by 2001.

That land should be subject to LVT.

Quite how one would value the land under Chatsworth House itself is open to question (suggestions please). The rule for valuing land is simple: what would someone pay for the land, with no buildings on it, if it had permission to build somewhere like Chatsworth? Maybe a Russian oligarch ("oligarch" translates as "thief") could answer that question!

If stately home owners can't generate enough income to cover the LVT they are free to sell off some of their land - as aristocratic families have been doing for centuries - or to apply to the taxpayer for support. We think such support is justified but we are opposed to taxpayers' money being given away as grants to anyone, for any reason - so any support would be by the way of a loan or by taxpayers (the state) taking a share in the business.

Well run places like Chatsworth can probably stand on their own two feet as businesses even with LVT. After all, a day out for two, looking round the garden, comes to over £50 by the time you have paid for the car park, entry and a sandwich for lunch.

Like many large landowners, Peregrine Andrew Morny Cavendish, 12th Duke of Devonshire, is a wealthy man - he is worth an estimated £1 billion so perhaps he doesn't need to turn to the taxpayer for a handout.

Chatsworth, like many other country estates, is already in receipt of significant public subsidies for land on which they pay no tax.